ATLANTA – With the 2025 Midsummer Classic fast approaching, early ballots are casting a clear picture of which stars fans want to see take center stage at Truist Park this July. The MLB All-Star Game 2025 early fan vote favorites include some expected names—and a few emerging surprises.
Judge Leads the American League With MVP Numbers
New York Yankees slugger Aaron Judge has long been a fan favorite, but his 2025 campaign is arguably his most dominant to date. Batting over .400 and leading the American League in home runs, RBIs, hits, and OPS, Judge isn’t just performing at an All-Star level—he’s pacing an MVP-caliber season. The Bronx captain is on pace to lock up his seventh All-Star selection with ease.
Alongside Judge, the youth movement is in full swing. Gunnar Henderson (Orioles) and Bobby Witt Jr. (Royals) have both made significant jumps in Phase 1 voting. Henderson, in particular, is powering a surging Baltimore lineup and showing the poise of a seasoned veteran. Witt, one of baseball’s most exciting shortstops, is flashing both glove and bat, making a strong case for his first All-Star start.
Ohtani, Freeman, and De La Cruz Power the NL Ballot
Over in the National League, the Los Angeles Dodgers’ dynamic duo of Shohei Ohtani and Freddie Freeman headline the fan tallies. Ohtani’s first year in Dodger blue has been nothing short of spectacular. Though limited on the mound, his bat has done the heavy lifting—17 homers, over 50 runs scored, and his usual mix of speed and power make him a must-watch selection.
Freeman, ever steady, is delivering a .368 average and a 1.087 OPS. His veteran leadership and consistent production have helped the Dodgers keep pace atop the National League and have fans clicking his name with confidence.
The National League’s most electrifying candidate, however, might be Elly De La Cruz. The Cincinnati shortstop is putting together a historic start to his career, recently becoming the only player in modern history to tally over 115 extra-base hits and 115 stolen bases within 300 games. His fearless play, highlight-reel baserunning, and powerful bat are turning heads across the country.
How Voting Works: Two-Phase Format Returns
Major League Baseball continues its two-phase voting format in 2025. In Phase 1, fans select their top players at each position. The leading vote-getter in each league earns an automatic starting spot in the All-Star Game. The next two highest vote recipients at each position then advance to Phase 2, where fans cast their votes again to determine the remaining starters.
Fans can vote up to five times per day on MLB.com, club websites, and the MLB app, making it easier than ever for supporters to back their favorites.
Atlanta’s Truist Park Set to Host the Stars
This year’s MLB All-Star Game will be held on Tuesday, July 15, at Truist Park, home of the Atlanta Braves. It will be the first time since 2000 that Atlanta has hosted the summer showcase. With its southern charm and modern amenities, Truist Park promises an unforgettable backdrop for baseball’s biggest stars.
With several weeks still remaining in the voting process, the standings are far from set. But if early returns are any indication, fans are leaning into the familiar excellence of superstars like Judge, Ohtani, and Freeman, while also embracing the fresh energy of players like De La Cruz, Witt Jr., and Henderson.
In a season full of standout performances, the MLB All-Star Game 2025 early fan vote favorites offer a glimpse of the names we’re likely to see shining under the Georgia lights come mid-July.
